Jamaica’s latest fiscal ‘problem’?

Newspaper reports this week in Jamaica indicated finance minister Audley Shaw saying Jamaica now had a fiscal surplus. I have not seen the actual data, but the report indicated that Jamaica’s primary surplus for the last fiscal year was J$136 billion, some 7.7 percent higher than programmed. Now, I have not seen a full table, so cannot be sure that the comments make sense in terms of the budget figures we normally see, but let’s put that technicality to one side, for the moment.

Now, there are several problems with this outcome. First, missing targets in an IMF program is not necessarily a good thing. Such programs are designed in a particular way; the elements have a certain coherence, so the level of the fiscal balance is meant to be consistent with the level of other variables, such as the stance of monetary policy, or the balance of payments position. Second, the nature of the miss is very important. In Jamaica’s case, were revenues higher than expected, spending lower than expected, or some combination? If tax policy was working as planned why would revenues be higher than expected? If government programmes were working as planned, why would spending be lower than expected. Were underlying economic conditions not as expected, or is something else going on that may be temporary or a new set of permanent circumstances are in play? Several months ago, minister of state in the ministry of finance, Fayval Williams, had spoken to the same fiscal surplus, but with more details: she indicated that capital spending had increased, but revenues had been higher than expected. Put differently, while the government was pushing money into the economy, it was drawing it out of the economy faster through taxation. Surely, this can’t be a strategy for accelerating growth!

Other implications of the country running a surplus instead of a deficit are important; a surplus clearly shows that the fiscal performance of the government is much tighter than program. Conventional economic theory suggests that a tighter fiscal program is more likely to have a negative impact on economic growth. So what Jamaica’s government is doing is working against fostering economic growth.

When I made my initial assessment of this year’s budget, I commented, as follows:

‘The Budget leaves the government still in the jaws of a dilemma: it does not convincingly push the needle towards the much vaunted growth target of 5 per cent growth within 4 years, the so-called ‘#5in4’.’

I also indicated that I thought the budget was going to be growth negative, meaning that growth would be less than it otherwise could be. The country running a fiscal surplus would seem to confirm that point: the government is drawing more resources out of the economy than intended. For the growth outcome to be as expected, then other sectors, namely private in ideals and corporations, need to be growing much faster than expected. Is that what is going on? Or, is the government’s growth strategy going badly off-struck by its own fiscal ‘success’?

On growth performance, the Planning Institute of Jamaica just told us that it was 0.3% in the quarter ended June, sluggish at best. It’s coming mainly from the impact of developments outside Jamaica, not domestic policy, PIOJ say. Weather (heavy rain) was also a negative factor–agriculture etc declined 8.5%–as it was positive, previously, but I keep saying weather isn’t a policy variable. Mining etc declined 10.5%; construction grew 1.5%, as did ‘industry’.

I see merely the tenderest of growing green shoots, if I look hard enough 🤔😩

Author: Dennis G Jones (aka 'The Grasshopper')

Retired International Monetary Fund economist. My blog is for organizing my ideas and thoughts about a range of topics. I was born in Jamaica, but spent 30 years being educated, living, and working in the UK. I lived in the USA for two decades, and worked and travelled abroad, extensively, throughout my careers and for pleasure. My views have a wide international perspective. Father of 3 girls. Also, married to an economist. :)

One thought on “Jamaica’s latest fiscal ‘problem’?”

  1. Reblogged this on Petchary's Blog and commented:
    My fellow blogger Dennis is an economist. I am sharing his thoughts on the Jamaican economy, because he is the expert – and because after the latest Planning Institute of Jamaica (PIOJ) quarterly press briefing, all kinds of questions were popping up in my mind. One of them was: Why is the weather always used as an excuse for a decline? And my major question was: How is the Jamaican Government actually going to foster economic growth – which is currently minimal? Even the tender green shoots are in danger of wilting and burning up (depending on the weather)…

    Liked by 1 person

Comments are closed.

Adventures from Elle

Your Guide to Jamaica & Beyond

Filosofa's Word

Cogito Ergo Sum


The blogging challenge keep you motivated and start the new year on the "write" track!

LBHF Libraries and Archives

"More than a library..."

Pointless Overthinking

Understanding ourselves and the world we live in.


Smile! You’re at the best WordPress.com site ever

The Accidental Ringer

thoughts from a novice ringer

Lluís Bussé

Barcelona's Multiverse | Art | Culture | Science


Who says Golf is everything?


My adventures as Founder, Director & Educator at Fundaciones Limited


International School of Riga - Director


Mindspace, unleashing a few truths, but mostly concerned with life and the way I see it.


Caribbean Woman, Paediatric Surgeon, Lover of Life

Albert Darnell Anderson

Just read, it'll inspire you!

"write pon di riddim"

multimodal site born to a decolonial feminist / cultural analyst / and dub doctor, Ph.D.

The Terrible Tout's Weblog

Just another WordPress.com weblog

CCRP Jamaica

Life to the Fullest!

%d bloggers like this: